Vote Labour? Never again

By Roger Protz

- Last updated on GMT

Related tags Pubs Beer Scotch whisky Chancellor Government

Protz: not a Labour fan
Protz: not a Labour fan
What on earth is the Government trying to do to pubs? Roger Protz can't believe its latest tax moves.

That familiar cry from the football terraces aimed at beleaguered managers — "You don't know what you're doing" — should also be roared at the Chancellor.

He seems hellbent on destroying pubs and breweries. Along with Gordon Brown and Peter Mandelson, Darling repeatedly proclaims his support for small businesses. But where pubs are concerned, he seems determined to ruin even more of them. You don't recognise pubs as small businesses, Chancellor? I have news for you: they are the elephant in the room.

Brewing and pub retailing employ close to one million people. They comprise one of our last major industries and retailers. Why do you want to drive them into oblivion, forcing large numbers into the dole queue, Chancellor?

On the morning of the Pre-Budget Report, I spoke to a City expert, a man who knows everything worth knowing about Government fiscal policy. "Do tell me," I pleaded, "he's not going to increase duty on beer again?" "Of course not," the sage replied. "The decrease in VAT will support pubs."

It's the kind of support the rope gives the hanging man. Out from left field, as the Americans say, came another unheralded, 8% rise in excise duty. The VAT decrease is a short-term measure. It will go up again. Excise duty is locked into an escalator that will see a further increase every year.

Every which way, pubs are kicked in the groin and, while they're writhing on the ground, kicked again for good measure. Five pubs are closing every day, Chancellor: how many more do you want to see go under?

But then it got worse. It so happens that Brown and Darling are Scots and — surprise, surprise — the Scotch whisky industry got on the blower, threatened to burn its collective kilt and demanded a rethink on the duty levied on the juice of the barley.

And, lo and behold, Darling turned turtle and halved the increase on duty on whisky to 4%.

While I'm in Scottish mode, I recall the witches in Macbeth: "By the pricking of my thumbs, something wicked this way comes." For wicked, read alcopops. By reducing the duty on whisky, Darling had also to cut it by the same amount for all spirits. And spirits include alcopops. Perhaps I've missed something, but isn't the Government worried about binge drinking and, in particular, young people drinking themselves into early graves by consuming these vile, sweet, noxious liquids known as alcopops?

Research shows that young women who over-indulge in alcopops run the risk of stacking up serious health problems. The dangers include giving birth to deformed babies. No matter: it's vital to keep the shock jocks happy. So cut the duty on whisky and, wa-hey, watch the sales of alcopops rocket. Surprisingly, I haven't heard a squeak of protest from Alcohol Concern.

Defying belief

Government attitudes to beer, brewing and pubs in 2008 almost defy belief. Never has an industry been so attacked, battered and holed below the water line. Pubs give pleasure to millions on a daily basis. They attract visitors and tourists. They provide employment for many thousands. So what do the wiseacres in Westminster do? Introduce so many barriers to trade that running a pub in England is about as much fun as watching England play rugby.

It would be a mistake to think the Conservatives offer anything better. They are scarcely good friends of brewing and pubs.

Remember the Monopolies Commission report of 1989 and the Beer Orders that flowed from it? Remember the "pubs for breweries" swaps nodded through by such geniuses as Michael Heseltine and Peter Lilley?

The result today is that giant pub companies treat pubs like supermarkets or petrol stations. They call customers "traffic", want to shovel them in and out of pubs as fast as possible, and offer them a simple choice of over-priced beers sourced from global brewers who sell their products at less than the cost of production.

Both the major political parties treat brewers as convenient milch cows. Hammer them, suck them dry, place every possible tax barrier in the way of them earning a decent living and, along the way, levy such crippling rates of duty on beer that even the most dedicated pub lover is forced into the unloving arms of the pile 'em high supermarkets.

But at the moment we are saddled with Brown and his scurvy crew. As a result of upbringing, inclination and social class, I have voted Labour all my life, but never again.

I apologise for dragging politics into the pages of the MA, but these are exceptional times. This is being written shortly after armed police, members of the counter-terrorism squad, arrested an opposition MP, invaded Parliament and took away his documents and computers.

Please don't tell us, Ms Smith and Mr Straw, that you knew nothing about this. You have lied to us before and you will lie to us again.

The last time I can recall armed men invading Parliament was when Oliver Cromwell dispersed the Rump Parliament in 1653. His words of anger and derision aimed at the assembled politicians echo down the years and today more than adequately serve notice on the present Government: "You have sat too long here for any good you have been doing. Depart, I say, and let us have done with you. In the name of God, go!"

Related topics Beer Legislation

Property of the week

KENT - HIGH QUALITY FAMILY FRIENDLY PUB

£ 60,000 - Leasehold

Busy location on coastal main road Extensively renovated detached public house Five trade areas (100)  Sizeable refurbished 4-5 bedroom accommodation Newly created beer garden (125) Established and popular business...

Follow us

Pub Trade Guides

View more