NIC cuts ‘obvious’ move to make hiring young people affordable

Migrant-pub-workers.jpg
Massive difference: Milburn Review set to propose phased employer NICs cuts

The Milburn Review’s proposed employer NIC cuts could save hospitality £170m a year, with operators saying lower employment costs would make a “massive difference” to recruitment.

According to reports, the review, led by former Labour health secretary Alan Milburn, will recommend doubling the employer National Insurance Contributions (NICs) threshold for 21–24-year-olds from £5,000 to £10,000.

Join our new WhatsApp channel: The Morning Round-Up

Get the biggest pub trade stories straight to your phone. Listen to our one-minute daily news briefing and receive breaking news, exclusives and sector updates throughout the day. Remember to turn notifications on in the top right corner! Join the channel here.

The proposal aims to cut youth employment costs and encourage businesses to create more entry-level jobs.

Frisco Group managing director Heath Ball told The Morning Advertiser (The MA) the reduction would make a “massive difference” for operators employing young people.

“If you want young people in work, making them more affordable to employ is the obvious place to start. I’m amazed it’s taken the Government this long to work it out,” he said.

Ball, who runs Top 50 Gastropub the Red Lion & Sun in Highgate, London, added the move would give operators more “freedom” when it came to recruitment.

“It’s hard to take a risk on someone when the cost of employing them is already so high,” he added.

Since 2024, the National Living Wage for those aged 21 and over has risen by 11%, from £11.44 to £12.71, alongside increases to employer NICs.

Really frightening

“On an illustrative £25,000 salary, the change in national insurance rates and thresholds adds £806 a year before any Employment Allowance. That’s not a figure from our accounts, but it shows the pressure before you even consider the other costs of running a pub,” he said.

Ball described the combined impact of rising employment costs as “brutal”, adding it was getting “harder and harder to make a living” for operators.

He also criticised the Government’s approach to business policy, characterising the current climate as “really frightening” for hospitality and small business owners.

“What scares me most is how short-sighted and reactionary this Government is,” Ball continued.

“They make decisions without thinking them through or consulting enough of the people who have to live with the consequences.”

He urged the Government to stop making employment a tax target: “If you want businesses to thrive and give young people opportunities, stop handcuffing them and let them get on with it.

“It’s deeply disappointing to be led by a Government that, frankly, has no idea how to run the country.”

Meanwhile, UKHospitality (UKH) estimated around 240,000 hospitality jobs would benefit from the proposed threshold increase, saving the sector £170m annually.

Breathing room

The trade body added businesses could save £750 per eligible full-time employee each year, with a pub employing 20 young people saving around £15,000 annually and a hotel employing 50 young people saving around £38,000.

UKH chief executive Allen Simpson said: “Increasing the employer NICs threshold for young people working in hospitality would be a bold and significant recommendation from Alan Milburn.”

Simpson said the proposal would recognise hospitality’s role in tackling the number of young people not in education, employment or training (NEETs), describing the sector as the largest employer of young people in the economy.

He added: “When implemented, it would significantly reduce employment costs for businesses and give the sector much-needed breathing room to do what it does best – creating jobs in every postcode.”

Simpson urged the Government to introduce the change in April, its earliest opportunity to do so, and said he looked forward to seeing the full report and continuing engagement with Milburn and the Government.

The British Beer and Pub Association (BBPA) also welcomed the reported proposals.

Chief executive Emma McClarkin said: “Brewers and pubs employ more than half a million young people, giving them lifelong skills, experience and a welcome first step on the career ladder.

“The cost of employing under 25s has rocketed, which is why we’ve long called for Government to cut the cost of giving them work. This is essential if we’re to keep offering them those vital opportunities that they simply wouldn’t get anywhere else.”

The review is due to be published on Tuesday 17 November, with the full detail of its recommendations expected to clarify how and when the proposed changes could be introduced.