Pub directors warned over personal liability for unpaid VAT

Business investment
Unpaid VAT: Pub directors warned over personal liability (Getty Images)

Pub operators are being urged to take HMRC warnings seriously amid reports of directors facing personal liability notices over unpaid tax debts.

Eddie Murphy, consultant for ELTA Licensed Trade Accountants, told The Morning Advertiser (MA) he had been advised of a licensee receiving a personal liability notice after falling behind on VAT and PAYE payments.

Join our WhatsApp channel: The Morning Round-Up

Get the biggest pub trade stories straight to your phone. Listen to our one-minute daily news briefing and receive breaking news, exclusives and sector updates throughout the day...Remember to turn notifications on in the top right corner! 

Join the channel here.

Murphy said he had also heard reports of similar cases through the licensee’s landlord, although he could not disclose further details due to client confidentiality.

He believes HMRC is taking a tougher approach to recovering unpaid tax, warning that operators already facing financial difficulties could be at risk if they fail to respond to correspondence.

“There has been a shift from HMRC,” Murphy said, urging licensees to open letters promptly and seek professional advice rather than ignoring demands for payment.

Directors’ liability

However, Sean Glancy, VAT partner at accountancy firm UHY Hacker Young, stressed that directors would not ordinarily become personally responsible for company VAT debts without specific legal grounds.

“This will normally only occur if there has been some sort of wrongdoing by the director. It is critical directors understand their statutory obligations to avoid a personal liability,” he said.

Glancy explained that genuinely struggling businesses could face enforcement if directors failed to meet their legal obligations, while repeated insolvencies used to avoid tax payments were a particular concern.

He added that VAT collected from customers could create cash flow difficulties when operators used the funds to cover immediate business costs before their quarterly payments became due.

HMRC has powers to issue joint and several liability notices in specific circumstances, including tax avoidance, evasion and repeated insolvency involving unpaid tax.

HMRC response

A HMRC spokesperson rejected suggestions of a change in its approach.

“Our approach remains the same, to recover the tax that’s due while supporting businesses experiencing financial difficulty. The vast majority of taxpayers pay what they owe, and company directors are not automatically liable for unpaid VAT owed by their company.”

HMRC confirmed that personal liability could only arise under specific statutory conditions, rather than simply because a limited company had outstanding VAT.

The department said it considers businesses’ individual circumstances and can offer Time to Pay arrangements, allowing outstanding tax to be repaid through affordable instalments.

Glancy urged publicans struggling with VAT obligations to speak to HMRC or their accountants as early as possible and maintain communication throughout any repayment agreement.

He also warned that businesses receiving letters from external debt collection agencies should verify that the agency is authorised by HMRC before making payments.

Murphy said: “Stay in close touch with HMRC,” adding that seeking professional help and responding to correspondence promptly remained the best approach for publicans facing tax arrears.