Sector calls for urgent action on Milburn Review

Bartender working in Pub, London, UK
Milburn Review: Sector calls for urgent action (Getty Images)

Trade bodies and operators have welcomed proposals to reduce the cost of employing young people in the Milburn Review, but warned the Government must act quickly to reverse the impact of rising employment costs.

Published on Tuesday 17 November by the Department for Work and Pensions, the review, led by former Labour health secretary Alan Milburn, set out recommendations to tackle youth unemployment.

Join our new WhatsApp channel: The Morning Round-Up

Get the biggest pub trade stories straight to your phone. Listen to our one-minute daily news briefing and receive breaking news, exclusives and sector updates throughout the day. Remember to turn notifications on in the top right corner! Join the channel here.

It proposed gradually increasing the employer NICs threshold for 21 to 24-year-olds from £5,000 to £10,000, initially in hospitality and retail, alongside changes to apprenticeships and guaranteed-hours legislation.

The review also made recommendations around apprenticeships and guaranteed-hours legislation, including retaining flexibility for seasonal employment.

However, it stated any changes would be introduced “when fiscal conditions allow”.

  • Read more about what the Milburn Review means for pubs here

Speaking to The Morning Advertiser (The MA), North South Leisure company director, Richard Grady, said making it easier and less costly to attract and employ young people was a positive step.

However, he warned it could take months or even years to reverse the impact of the Government’s NICs changes, which he said had already done significant damage.

Grady also called for a reduction in VAT, arguing it was a measure the Government could introduce quickly to give hospitality businesses the breathing space needed to survive and thrive.

Major entry points

He continued: “Hospitality and retail are not simply sectors that employ young people; they are major entry points into employment.

“Policies that increase employment costs or discourage recruitment could disproportionately affect the very age group this review is trying to help.”

The need to reduce employment costs was echoed by UKHospitality (UKH) chief executive Allen Simpson, who welcomed the review’s recognition of hospitality’s role in tackling the NEETs crisis.

However, he warned rising employment costs had already led to the loss of some 100,000 hospitality jobs, adding the sector’s tax burden needed to be reduced in order to unlock thousands of new employment opportunities.

Simpson said doubling the employer NICs threshold for hospitality would provide an “immediate shot in the arm” for job creation, protecting 240,000 roles and creating thousands more opportunities across the sector.

“Alan Milburn was asked a question and has given the right answer. It needs to be implemented,” he added.

Meanwhile, British Beer and Pub Association (BBPA) CEO Emma McClarkin stressed the importance of swift action, urging the Government to implement the proposals as soon as possible rather than waiting for fiscal conditions to allow it.

She said brewers and pubs employed more than half a million young people, providing lifelong skills, experience and a first step on the career ladder.

However, the BBPA warned the cost of employing under-25s had risen by 20% since 2025, meaning pubs paid approximately £5,000 more, on average, to hire a 21-24-year-old.

More affordable

McClarkin also backed plans to increase apprenticeship numbers but raised concerns over proposed restrictions on using levy funding for apprentices aged 25 or over, stating these would not support the longer-term development and retention of skilled staff.

Elsewhere, Greene King CEO Nick Mackenzie pointed to the cost pressures facing hospitality businesses, adding the review acknowledged the barriers NICs and upcoming guaranteed-hours legislation were creating for the sector’s ability to hire young people.

He further supported the review’s recommendation for caution around introducing guaranteed hours, stating pubs needed to retain the flexibility to offer young people seasonal jobs.

“With more than one million young people not in education, employment or training, pubs have a unique ability to offer first jobs, flexible employment and engaging careers.

“We are ready to play our part and urge the Government to listen to these recommendations, work with the industry and quickly implement the changes,” Mackenzie said.

Young’s chief executive Simon Dodd similarly welcomed proposals to make it easier for businesses to give young people their first step into work.

He said hospitality had long played an important role in offering flexible roles, allowing people to build skills and experience around education and other commitments.

Dodd added: “At a time when employment costs are rising, measures that make it more affordable to hire younger workers will help us continue creating those opportunities.”

Following the release of the report, Secretary of State for Work and Pensions Pat McFadden MP accepted several headline recommendations from the report.

Speaking in the House of Commons on Tuesday 17 November, McFadden pledged to respond to the Milburn Review with a White Paper and legislation in the new year.